The Hamptons' Non-Milkshake Milkshake ☕, Travel Cards & Offers - Wonder Shuffle

Find out more about The Hamptons' Non-Milkshake Milkshake ☕ and all the latest Travel deals with our cards that you can share with friends at Wonder Shuffle.sag-harbors-non-milkshake-milkshake-dreamycoffeecoMain travel categoryUser dreamycoffeeco
The Hamptons' Non-Milkshake Milkshake ☕Recipe tips for Dreamy's Cold Brew
Published 6/26/2025
2
0
3
0
Comments
User
dreamycoffeeco

From Ian, of Dreamy Coffee:


The Milkshake Revolution

Morning pick-me-up? Afternoon refresher? After-dinner treat? The beauty of Dreamy Coffee’s cold brew is that it’s smooth and mellow and makes for a perfect non-milkshake milkshake.


Each cold brew concentrate brings its own personality to your cup:


The Purist — Colombian single-source, versatile with water or milk


Dreamy — Peruvian beans with our proprietary hint of chocolate 


Hazelnut — Subtle nutty notes from Peruvian beans


Coconut — Tropical undertones that transport you instantly


The Non-Milkshake Milkshake Preparation

For the chocolatey Dreamy drink, use a one-to-one ratio with your milk of choice (almond, oat, pistachio all work beautifully). 


For the delicate notes of Hazelnut or Coconut, use a quarter milk, and a quarter purified water so you don't overwhelm those subtle flavors. 


Inside Tips 💯


1. The beauty of cold brew concentrate? It transforms just as easily into hot coffee — just add boiling water 1:1 for that same smooth experience without the chill.


2. Our cold brew is small-batch - five gallons at a time, made fresh daily. The 12-16 hour extraction eliminates the heat element that typically extracts acids and creates bitterness. 


3. Our partnership with Banana Bread Bakery in California wasn't random - a cup of cold brew and a slice of banana bread were made for pairing. 


Contacts


The Dreamy Coffee Co.


🍌 Gone Bananas Bread

The Dream-iest Coffee in Southampton ☕ A Sag Harbor connection worth sipping; now at Barryville General

The Hamptons' Non-Milkshake Milkshake ☕

Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA


About 

Ian Montgomery grew from punk rocker to Seattle tech worker to global nomad, exploring Colombia and Peru where he met his wife Elizabeth before settling in the Hamptons in 2022. As COO of Dreamy Coffee Co., he has partnered with founder Lynda Sylvester to expand their premium, small-batch coffee throughout the East End and beyond. Ian’s journey reflects the brand's ethos - breaking free from conventional limits to create something exceptional that connects people across continents through dreamy coffee and shared experiences.


Lead-in Image

@dreamycoffeeco / Instagram


Category: Travel
#travel
#northamerica
#newyork
#sagharbor
#hamptons
#food
#drink
#coffee
#milkshakes
#dessert

















COOKIE TIME.
Cookies help to customize the content we deliver to you and keep track of points prior to creating an account.
By clicking “Accept All Cookies” we can make sure you get the best Wonder Shuffle experience. If you’d like to learn more, please visit our Cookie Choices and make selections as you wish.