It’s Wednesday night in Sag Harbor, and that means one thing to local insiders: Limitless Lobster at The American Hotel.
This is a local tradition that used to only be available during off-season, where you can eat as many steamed lobsters as you want for a set price.
It comes with a baked potato and corn, and they’ll swap in a fresh lobster as soon as you finish your last one. The record? We’ve heard eight lobsters in one sitting. Most make it to three.
The summer season has come but the offer is still open. Go now, otherwise you may need to wait until September.
49 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA
This card was written by Rory and Grainne of Kidd Squid, a craft brewery, tasting room and beer garden in Sag Harbor, NY. Click on our avatar above to see more of our local finds and inside tips.
The American Hotel Sag Harbor / Instagram
Be in the Know.
Built for expats and global travellers, Wonder Shuffle is the ultimate travel and lifestyle platform to help its cultured and curious members uncover hidden gems, organize their discoveries, and recall them effortlessly.
DJK Universal Holdings Limited
Latest News
🎵 The Daily Beat — Music Hidden Gems Inside
Your Hamptons Market Map Awaits 🧺
Breakfast in the Hamptons 🍳🥐
Our Story
About Us
Premium Accounts
Points & Loyalty
FAQs
The Wonder Shuffle Pledge
Useful Links
Privacy
Terms & Conditions
Site Map
Contact Us
Get the Newsletter