From Francesca Buffo, founder of Lady Holiday:

My Vintage Hunting Strategy

When thrifting, I always recommend focusing on classic pieces to add to your wardrobe.

Look for timeless blazers, trench coats (sometimes you'll find a great Burberry!), well-made shoes that just need new heels, and versatile handbags.

For the best finds, visit midweek when new stock has arrived but before weekend crowds. The Retreat offers significant discounts during their end-of-month or first Friday sales - perfect for splurging on higher-priced items.

Inside Tips 💎 

🏠 Always check ARF's basement first as most shoppers focus on furniture upstairs (this card mapped to ARF's ).

👗 Don't miss the second barn at Queen of Most Holy Rosary where their best clothing hides.

🧵 The Retreat's kimono collection is exceptional - I've found gorgeous ones for lounging at home.

💰 For exceptional designer finds at non-Hamptons prices, bring cash to the Hospital Opportunity Shop in Greenport, just off the ferry.

🍽️ Complete your thrifting day trip with a fresh meal at Noah's in Greenport for the perfect sustainable shopping experience.

See individual cards below to save to your Wonder Shuffle map!

Contacts

🌐 Lady Holiday

🌐 ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop

🌐 The Exchange Thrift Shop

🌐 The Retreat Boutique

🌐The Eastern Long Island Hospital Opportunity Shop

🌐 Noah's

About

Lady Holiday started thrift shopping in the Hamptons as a little girl. A magical shop in Bridgehampton became her favorite place to dig through bins and baskets of fabrics, gems, stones, handbags, and clothes. That store - now long gone - sparked her imagination and planted the seed for what would become her signature style: a life built on reimagined vintage, feminine flair, and the joy of finding something new... for you.

Lead-in Image

@theretreatboutique / Instagram